Best Reciprocating Saws

Summary

No shop would be complete without a reliable reciprocating saw. Basement DIYers and professional contractors alike recognize the versatility of this tool in just about any area and would not be caught without one.

To help you figure out which recipro saw to go for, we have decided to put together this brief guide. We’ll talk about some of the best saws available today and give you a few other options if our choices don’t quite sound right to you.

Introduction

When we were taking our first few steps towards professional remodeling, we did have our fair share of encounters with reciprocating saws we thought were great but ended up disappointing us after just a couple of uses.

This is because the true value of a reciprocating saw goes way beyond its name and design. You have to look closely and see what features it has. You have to listen to what other consumers think and what their experiences were like with each product.

Now that we have used more than enough reciprocating saws to last a lifetime, we have discovered some key product features that are guaranteed to make a good saw.

Top 3 Choices

1) DEWALT DCS387B MAX Compact Reciprocating Saw

We decided to give the top spot to the DCS387B because of the versatility, power, convenience, and durability it offers. It works equally great in light cutting jobs and in heavy-duty work. Moreover, it is able to do cutting techniques that many other saws can’t quite pull off. It also has a bonus feature of an LED that illuminates the work area.

2) Milwaukee 2625-20 M18 Hackzall Cordless One-Handed Reciprocating Saw

Weighing merely 4.4 pounds and measuring 13.4 inches long, leading power tool manufacturer Milwaukee’s 2625-20 M18 Hackzall is a compact and lightweight recipro saw. Because of its built, it is highly portable and comfortable to use even when cutting overhead and at other odd angles. It has variable speed control that lets you freely adjust and match the material you are cutting. Its stroke length is optimized for making precise and fast cuts on various material types. Milwaukee also added a few nice touches to this tool, such as the LED and the anti-vibration system.

3) BLACK+DECKER BDCR20B MAX Lithium Reciprocating Saw

What we like the most about this saw from Black+Decker is that it does not attempt to be many things. It is a neat little saw designed and built to be lightweight and compact while producing a lot of power that can handle many light to moderate cutting operations. It also comes fitted with handy ease-of-use features that may appear insignificant on paper but help a lot on the worksite.

Best Reciprocating Saws Comparison Table

Best Reciprocating Saws

Our Rating

Price

DEWALT DCS387B MAX Compact Reciprocating Saw

Milwaukee 2625-20 M18 Hackzall Cordless One-Handed Reciprocating Saw

BLACK+DECKER BDCR20B MAX Lithium Reciprocating Saw

Who Should Buy These

Reciprocating saws are most commonly known for and used in demolition work. If you see anything that needs to be taken down or completely destroyed, you need to have a reciprocating saw handy to take care of it.

Take note that it does not stop at simply buying a recipro saw and cutting away at the material you want to get rid of. There are a lot of things to keep in mind in order to achieve your preferred results. Do you need a high-speed saw or is a low-speed one okay? Is it necessary to have variable speed or are you going to be fine with fixed speed saws?

To put it simply, reciprocating saws are for people who understand what they are used for and know what the numbers mean in terms of applications.

Buyer's Guide

Shopping for reciprocating saws can be confusing at times due to the sheer number of choices available. Cut your decision making in half by remembering the following specs to look for:

Amperage

Amperage is power. If you will mostly be using your reciprocating saw for a few small projects here and there around the home, you will be fine with less than 10 amps. For one-time, big projects, a 10- or 11-amp recipro saw should be able to do the trick. However, if you are a contractor who will be using the saw rather heavily, you need to get the most powerful saw you can find--usually 15-amp ones.

Blade Movement

Recipro saw blades can be straight (moves back and forth) or orbital (moves elliptically). Straight saws are ideal for cutting into harder materials while orbital ones are preferred for relatively softer materials.

Variable Speed Control

Find a saw with variable speed settings if you will be using your saw for a lot of different materials and cutting operations. Meanwhile, if you think you have very limited use for your saw, you may do well with a fixed speed saw.

Weight

You won’t appreciate a lightweight recipro saw until you have tried cutting for hours using a heavy one. It is important that you use a saw you can comfortably hold and operate, especially if you do a lot of overhead cutting.

Stroke Length

The length of the saw’s stroke is what determines the cutting rate and the amount of material taken out at a time. If you are looking to destroy a hulking piece of plaster that does not contain anything important, you can use a saw with a long stroke. On the other hand, if you will be working with thinner materials, you can instead go for saws with shorter strokes.

Product Reviews

Description

One of the things you will like about the DCS387B is its multi-position blade clamp. This part design allows you to make flush cuts, especially when cutting a pipe flush against a large, flat surface. This DeWalt recipro saw has variable speed control with a range of 0-2,900 strokes per minute. It also has an LED bulb that greatly helps in low-visibility worksites. Looking over at the business end of the saw, you will notice a pivoting shoe that helps maintain stability during cutting. Overall, we like how the DCS387B is sleek and compact enough to fit even between studs and other confined spaces.

Product Information

  • Length: 14.5 in
  • Weight: 5.4 lbs
  • Speed: 0-2,900 spm
  • Power Source: Battery
  • Voltage: 20V
  • Stroke Length: 1 ⅛ in

Features and Benefits

  • Four-Position Blade Clamp

The multi-position blade clamp allows you to install the blade upright or sideways, with the right side up or down, left or right. This gives the saw maximum versatility in terms of cutting application and proves to be very useful when making flush cuts.

  • Variable Speed Control

Variable speed control lets you match your cutting speed with the material you are cutting and helps you achieve the kind of cut you are going for. One hidden benefit of this, though, is extending the saw’s life. By being able to cut dense materials slowly, you are cutting efficiently without compromising the blade.

The speed trigger is right on the handle where you can easily press it without having to look anywhere other than the blade.

  • Pivoting Shoe

The pivoting shoe comes as a standard design feature in many reciprocating saws today. However, few manufacturers get it right and do it as well as DeWalt does. The pivoting shoe on the DCS387B is surprisingly very stable and durable and manages to remain in contact with the material throughout the cutting operation.

  • Cordless Design

This recipro saw is battery-powered, meaning all you have to worry about when taking it out to a worksite is having enough spare. No need to worry about power outlets in the middle of nowhere for as long as you have enough battery juice packed.

Pros

  • Blade clamp design provides flexibility and versatility
  • Vertical motor position is well-balanced
  • Has variable speed control via trigger

Cons

  • No brushless motor

Description

This time around, renowned tool company Milwaukee offers a nicely designed, compact, and lightweight reciprocating saw that operates on battery. The 2625-20 M18 Hackzall is only 13.4 inches long and 4.4 inches light. Its size allows it to be used comfortably when cutting at difficult angles and areas for extended periods. Its powerful motor is capable of cutting at a variable speed of up to 3,000 strokes per minute with a stroke length of 0.75 inches. The length of the Hackzall’s stroke is just enough to fulfill quick cutting requirements that require relatively more precision. It is also perfect for cutting into thinner materials or those located close to other materials that you can’t risk damaging. Finally, the Hackzall comes fitted with a built-in LED bulb and has a dual-gear anti-vibration system that helps reduce fatigue and improve cutting accuracy.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 13.4 x 7.2 x 3.4 in
  • Weight: 4.4 lbs
  • Speed: Variable (0-3,000 spm)
  • Stroke Length: ¾ in
  • Power Source: Battery (Cordless)
  • Voltage: 18V

Features and Benefits

  • Cordless Design

Since the 2625-20 M18 Hackzall is cordless, you are given full maneuverability when cutting. It allows you to cut in tight areas, bad angles, overhead locations, and other places you normally can’t get to with a cord in the way.

The other great thing about having a cordless reciprocating saw like the Hackzall is that you can bring it to remote worksites without having to worry about power outlets, bulky extension cords, and heavy generators. You only need to have good batteries in stock and know how long each one lasts so you can prepare beforehand.

  • Anti-Vibration System

An anti-vibration mechanism is something you normally ignore until you have tried cutting for long periods of time and endured double the fatigue you usually experience because of a tool’s vibration. In the case of the 2625-20 M18 Hackzall, their dual-gear anti-vibration system makes all the difference.

Since the device cushions or absorbs some of that vibration from the tool, you get more stability and accuracy and less exhaustion.

  • Light Weight and Compact Design

The 2625-20 M18 Hackzall is so small and light that storage and transportation should be the least of your worries. You can hang it from your belt and go about your day and not so much as notice its weight.

  • Variable Speed Control

Variable speed control gives you many benefits, including the ability to adjust your cutting speed to the material you are working with (Some materials are better cut at low speeds while some are more efficiently handled at high cutting speeds.). It also gives you full flexibility in terms of cut type or quality (Generally, the higher the speed, the rougher the cut). Finally, this feature also indirectly helps in prolonging the life of your saw. By cutting at slower speeds, you are able to work with dense materials without the risk of overheating the recipro saw.

The Hackzall’s speed control trigger juts out from just under the handle, within reach of your finger. The button’s location lets you easily adjust the cutting speed without requiring you to take your eyes off what you are cutting.

Pros

  • It is light, compact, and portable.
  • Variable speed allows for flexibility.
  • The LED and the anti-vibration features are nice.

Cons

  • A little water can cause it to stall.

Description

This reciprocating saw from Black+Decker weighs only 3.8 lbs, making it lightweight and portable enough for many of us who have to travel a lot with it. It has a powerful, high-performance motor with a variable speed range of 0-3,000 strokes per minute, with each stroke measuring ⅞ inch. This much stroke length is ideal for cutting through relatively thinner materials or those sandwiched between delicate corners that you do not want to damage.

It also has a pivoting shoe and a tool-free blade change system in place, which greatly add to the convenience of using this saw. The other thing we appreciate about this is that it comes with a saw blade, which other bare-tool items do not include.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 15.6 x 3.4 x 7.1 in
  • Weight: 3.8 lbs
  • Power Source: Battery (Cordless)
  • Speed: Variable (0-3,000 spm)
  • Stroke Length: ⅞ in
  • Voltage: 20V

Features and Benefits

  • Cordless Design

Without a cord, the BDCR20B can get into tight spaces that corded saws usually have difficulty maneuvering through. It is also convenient in that you can use it anywhere without the need for an outlet.

  • Variable Speed Control

With direct access to this unit’s fully variable speed control, you get to quickly adjust your cut. Go faster for a rougher cut or slower for a more precise cut.

  • Tool-Free Blade Change System

Changing blades does not require the use of wrenches, unlike other recipro saw models. If you look near the business end of the BDCR20B, there is a lever near the blade mount that you flip open to release the old blade and flip back down to lock the new blade in position.

Pros

  • Short strokes are good for more precise cutting work
  • Smart blade change mechanism

Cons

  • Can vibrate too much

Description

The DWE304 comes packed with a powerful motor and a sturdy body optimized for heavy-duty applications. Like the earlier DeWalt model, this one has a four-position blade clamp design, which allows for flush cutting, among others. It has variable speed control and can cut anywhere between 0 to 2,800 strokes per minute with 1 ⅛-inch strokes. This stroke length combined with a relatively low max speed is ideal for making rough cuts through dense or hard materials. The stroke length makes deep cuts while the low speed limit ensures that the saw does not overheat in the process.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 19.2 x 9.4 x 4 in
  • Weight: 9.2 lbs
  • Power Source: Corded
  • Speed: Variable (0-2,800 spm)
  • Stroke Length: 1 ⅛ in
  • Voltage: 120V

Features and Benefits

  • Corded

Cordless saws are great, but they will never equal the power of corded saws like the DWE304. Furthermore, having a saw plugged in means you never have to worry about running out of battery mid-cut.

  • Solid Built

This model may be a little heavier than the others, but that it for a very good reason. It is made of high-grade materials that are designed to withstand heavy use and abuse. The DWE304 is guaranteed to stay intact regardless of the amount of work it does at any one time.

  • Cutting Capacity

The DWE304 is armed with a relatively low speed limit and an impressively long stroke, making it ideal for making slow, deep cuts in tough materials. The long stroke ensures you get to remove as much material as possible while the low speed prevents the saw from overheating even if you use it for extended work periods.

Pros

  • Designed for heavy-duty cutting
  • Can work hard for a long while

Cons

  • Not too portable; best to have a case for it

5) Ryobi P515 ONE Plus Cordless Reciprocating Saw w/ Anti-Vibe Handle

Description

Another cordless recipro saw, the P515 from Ryobi can cut even in hard-to-reach corners. You can use it comfortably even when cutting at overhead angles because it features an anti-vibe handle which reduces the transfer of vibration from the tool to your arm. This delays, if not totally eliminates, the onset of fatigue.

Meanwhile, the handle is designed with an overmolded handle with micro texture. This is to optimize it for superior comfort and good grip. It has a tool-free blade change system in place in the form of its uniquely designed blade clamp. Its powerful motor can cut at a speed of 3,100 strokes per minute.

Product Information

  • Speed: 3,100 SPM
  • Dimensions: 6 x 15 x 6 in
  • Weight: 4 lbs
  • Voltage: 18V
  • Power Source: Battery-powered

Features and Benefits

  • Cordless Design

The P515 is cordless, making it flexible enough for cutting in confined areas and convenient enough for use in remote jobsites with no electricity.

  • Anti-Vibe Handle

With an ingeniously designed anti-vibe handle, the P515 lets you focus more on your operation than on trying to keep your arm steady and enduring the exhaustion aggravated by the tool’s vibration.

Pros

  • Handle design lets you cut more precisely and comfortably
  • Cordless power source provides convenience and flexibility

Cons

  • Blade change mechanism is not too durable

Reviews / Testimonials

What most people seem to love about this saw is its performance, seeing how it cuts remarkably into nearly any material type. Although this DeWalt recipro saw falls within the middle price range, it surely delivers results comparable to those of more expensive saws.

Oddly enough, many of the negative comments about the DCS387B are about the fact that it does not come with a battery or a charger. However, we do not want to count that against the saw because they by no means affect the tool’s performance.

Overall, the DCS387B seems to be a popular choice among new and experienced workers alike because of its versatility and top-notch features.

Top 3 Reciprocating Saws By Category

Best Cordless Reciprocating Saws Comparison Table

Best Cordless Reciprocating Saws

Our Rating

Price

DEWALT DCS387P1 20-volt MAX Lithium Ion Compact Reciprocating Saw

DEWALT DCS310S1 12-Volt MAX Pivot Reciprocating Saw

DEWALT Bare-Tool DC385B 18-Volt Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Best Corded Reciprocating Saws Comparison Table

Best Corded Reciprocating Saws

Our Rating

Price

DEWALT DWE305 12 Amp Corded Reciprocating Saw