Best Spindle Sanders

Summary

Every woodworker has had the daunting experience of sanding a curved edge or piece before. It’s painstaking, extremely difficult and one false move and, your piece is headed to the trash bin. It’s rare for anyone, even a seasoned woodworker or a hobbyist to have a steady hand especially in sanding, grinding and finishing something as intricate as a curved edge. This is where spindle sanders come handy. A spindle sander won’t just sand edges with ease but will give you more control than manual sanding will ever give. Simply choose the sanding sleeve that you need to use and attach it to the machine and presto! You would have a smooth, curved piece in no time.

This guide was created to help woodworkers, hobbyists and even contractors to find the most efficient spindle sander. The best sander basically has to have all three features: it should be easy to operate, has a variety of on-board tools and attachments and it should be right for the money. There are a number of good brands and models out there and this review will be useful in making an informed and quality choice.

Introduction

Being a woodworker and a hobbyist, I have come to use a variety of machines for finishing, grinding and sanding. From belt sanders, disc sanders to spindle sanders, you name it I have used it and maybe even broken a few because of the high demands of my work and hobby. And because of my extensive experience, I have come to know a few trusted brands when it comes to power sanders. These brands have more than face value; these brands actually have sanders that REALLY work.

Spindle sanders are actually one of the most important tools in my shed and I have come to rely on one solid brand. But my choice was not to the whim. I have worked with local brands and foreign spindle sanders and have spent a lot of money buying one sander after the other when one broke down. After years of looking, I finally had the most suitable spindle sander that works perfectly for my woodworking job.

The following power spindle sanders are my top three:

Top 3 Choices

1) WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander

WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander

The WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander is a powerful sander which has a 1/3 HP 3.5 Amp motor that provides 58 OPM and 2000 RPM. This woodworking machine could sand, grind, shape, smooth and even sharpen with its efficient motor that will never let you down. The machine has an array of accessories including 6 sanding sleeve sizes for creating different curves: ½ in, ¾ in, 1 in, 1 ½ in, 2 in and 3 in. All accessories can be placed on the machine so you can easily find what you need and prevents losing accessories and parts. It has a dust collection port that will reduce clean up. You will be able to work and clean as you go. This WEN spindle sander is backed by a 2 year warranty

2) Triton TSPS450 Oscillating Spindle Sander

Triton TSPS450 Oscillating Spindle Sander

The Triton TSPS450 Oscillating Spindle Sander is a sander built for almost all kinds of sanding, finishing and grinding work and will efficiently create arcs, curves and other types of irregular shapes. It has an efficient 3.5 Amp motor with a no load speed of 2000 RPM and oscillation speed of 58 RPM. It also has a wide array of accessories featuring 6 sanding sleeves, rubber drums and table inserts. These accessories may be placed on the machine itself with special inserts along its sides. This Triton spindle sander is efficient and easy to carry anywhere; you can take it at home or at the shop.

3) Grizzly G0538 1/3 HP Oscillating Spidle Sander

Grizzly G0538 1-3 HP Oscillating Spidle Sander

The Grizzly G0538 is an oscillating spindle sander that promises smooth, easy curved edges even if you have very little room in your shop. This sander is very straightforward because it’s a benchtop version which you can carry and use almost everywhere. It has a powerful motor that will get sanding jobs done fast with everything smooth and perfect. This sander also has a quick change sanding drum that will let you make drum changes fast so you can proceed and finish the next job quickly.

Best Spindle Sanders Comparison Table

Best Spindle Sanders

Our Rating

Price

WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander

Triton TSPS450 Oscillating Spindle Sander

Grizzly G0538 1/3 HP Oscillating Spidle Sander

Who Should Buy These

Spindle sanders are essential for all woodworkers. Not only are these power tools perfect for sanding curved edges and rounded curves but these get the job done fast minus the worries and stress of making mistakes. Therefore this machine is for woodworkers who cannot afford to make mistakes. It is for the cautious yet experienced woodworker who wants to get the job done perfectly the first time.

There is no doubt wood and other materials used for projects cost a lot, and it could cost more if you are using quality, expensive wood or other substrates. You won’t be able to afford getting anything wrong; a single wrong move could ruin everything and you will surely start from scratch. This is why a spindle sander is preferred for creating intricate curves and edges.

Spindle sanders are for contractors too. This machine works harder at the shop and will even work harder in the field. Nothing could be as efficient as a spindle sander and it will work definitely better than manually sanding a part.

This power tool is for people who are new to woodworking. Beginner woodworkers will be able to learn how to shape curves perfectly, how to use each type of sleeve and how to efficiently handle and shape irregular pieces. They will learn the satisfaction of having to hold a piece on their hand and shape it according to their task at hand. Efficiently using a spindle sander and practicing every project will be able to train a beginner to work perfectly for all projects. 

Buyer's Guide

The Benefits of Spindle Sanders

Gets jobs curved edges done fast and perfectly

Spindle sanders will get the curved edges done fast and even in the best time compared to just sanding the piece manually. It rotates fast (even faster depending on the capacity of the motor) and this moves and rotates the spindle moving the sanding sleeve. You can change the sleeves according to the size of curvature that you want to create. Changing sleeves is even easy since you only have to stop the motor and make a quick change. No other additional tools to get this done.

Reduces fatigue and strain

Manual sanding will lead to hand pain, wrist and arm pain and so on. And of course pain only makes everything worse; you will never be able to finish sanding and shaping if your hand and arm is in total pain. It is also a fact that no one can really be able to create curves perfectly; even the most experienced woodworker will tell you they have had difficulty in making irregular shapes and curves. Only a can get the job done, minus the pain and stress of sanding.

Saves you time and effort

A spindle sander will save you time in creating tough curves and intricate shapes and of course you also save effort in doing so. There is no doubt that it is very inefficient to work manually even for a small piece; what more if you need to finish or shape a larger and more intricate piece of material? A spindle sander will get the job done fast and will even leave you room to perfect your work. You will have more time to do more work and you won’t be tired at the end of the day. Now that’s the most important feature for any woodworker or hobbyist.

Finish different tasks using one tool with complete accessories

Most popular spindle sander brands have all the attachment and accessories you need and this makes any job more efficient. All the possible curve sizes are available from the smallest ½ inch to 3 inches and corresponding discs are also with the tool as well. No need to purchase separate tools and sanding machines when you got all the accessories and attachments that you need.

Features to Look for in Spindle Sanders

Take note of the following spindle sander features to be able to make an excellent decision.

Motor capacity - usual motor capacities are from a ½ to ¾ HP and definitely the more powerful your motor is, the stronger your spindle sander. But sometimes, you need a gentler motor to allow you to work efficiently and perfectly. Therefore a ½ HP may be the best choice for power and precision work. Tool motor capacity, HP and RPM are usually listed on the tool’s website or from its Amazon product page, you won’t miss it.

Onboard accessories – take note of the tool’s onboard attachments and accessories. This will make it easier for workers to use the tool and saves time looking for the appropriate attachment as well. Most spindle sanders have spaces for these attachments so you won’t lose any.

Dimensions and weight – the Goldilocks rule applies to this feature. The spindle sander has to be heavy enough to stand or sit on the table or workspace as you work but it must be light enough to take anywhere. But if you are not planning to take it to the worksite or to anywhere then weight won’t be an issue for you. You need a sander that will occupy only a small portion of your workspace and not the entire table; it must also be handy and easy to store away after your work is done. The dimensions of the tool must be considered if you plan to store it away in a cabinet or storage space.

Easy change attachments – usually spindle sander attachments such as sanding sleeves are very easy to remove and replace. Just turn off the machine and remove the sleeve and then replace it with a new one. Make sure you are getting an easy change spindle sander but check for any reviews regarding non-staying sleeves and hard to change sanding sleeves.

Special features – there is nothing much to say about special features since most spindle sanders have a very straightforward and easy design. But possibly a handy feature to watch out for is a dust port which I find very handy. Not all spindle sanders have this feature. This allows you to sand without accumulating a lot of dirt and dust on your working area. You won’t have to deal with all the messy clean up afterwards. Some sanders have the dust port directly near the spindle area while some are at the back so you may need to use a hose or a simple attachment to remove dust fast.

Warranty – most products come with a 2 year warranty; you’ll get lucky if you find 3 or 4 years. This is because a sander is used more frequently than other woodworking tools and if you plan to use yours but can’t get more than two years, you can otherwise get extended warranty for it. Extended warranties are available from where you likely purchased your spindle sander.

Price – a lot of woodworkers will probably tell you that quality is synonymous with an expensive price. Not me, I believe that there are quality products out there that are just being overlooked. You don’t have to spend more just to get the best value tool. You must therefore compare different spindle sanders accordingly to get a tool for the best value, features and price.

Product Reviews

1) WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander

WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander

Description

The WEN 6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander is a compact and powerful sander that will let you work with curved edges and different shapes minus the worries of making a mistake. This sander has a powerful motor that provides 58 OPM and 2000 RPM. This could sand, grind, shape, smooth and sharpen with its efficient motor. The machine all the accessories you need including 6 sanding sleeve sizes for creating different curves: ½ in, ¾ in, 1 in, 1 ½ in, 2 in and 3 in. All accessories have special slots on the machine so you can easily find what you need. You will never lose accessories and parts with the WEN 6510. It has a dust collection port so you can work and clean as you go. This WEN spindle sander has a 2 year warranty.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 20.3 x 15.5 x 24 inches
  • Weight: 9.2 pounds
  • Shipping weight: 9.2 pounds
  • Power source: corded-electric
  • Country of origin: China
  • Color: black and orange
  • Warranty: two year warranty

Features and Benefits

  • Compact design

There is no doubt that you can work easily with this machine because it has a very straightforward and simple design. You won’t find any complicated attachment or anything that will complicate your use. It is also easy to take anywhere because it is lighter than most spindle sanders. It will also be easy to store or keep away since it is small enough to fit in a cabinet or storage space. It won’t take up much room on your workspace counter either.

  • Powerful ½ motor

The WEN 6510 has a powerful motor that will seamlessly work for almost all substrates and materials, cut shapes and smoothens edges for that beautiful finish and will allow you to cut and finish irregular shapes as well. The powerful motor will also let you work effortlessly and faster compared to manually sanding a part.

  • Includes a variety of sanding sleeves

Name the size of sanding sleeve and grit that you need and you’ll have it. The tool comes with six sanding sleeves as well as all the common curves that you need. All these can be stored on-board so you won’t lose a single piece.

  • Dust collector port

Now this is my favorite part, the WEN 6510 has a dust port which is not too popular with spindle sanders. This port will suck up all the dirt and dust from your workstation and this allows you to have a clear view of what you are doing. Sanding is very intricate work and having minimal dirt and dust on your working area will make the job less strenuous and even more efficient.

  • With two-year warranty

It is rare that you will find anything longer as two years but it’s worth the shot. The WEN 6510 offers a two-year warranty and this protects users form unforeseen worries when using the spindle sander. You can otherwise purchase an additional warranty for the machine as soon as you purchase it.

Pros

  • Powerful motor
  • With dust collection port
  • On-board accessories
  • Compact design
  • Lightweight

Cons

  • Price too steep

2) Triton TSP450 Oscillating Spindle Sander

Triton TSPS450 Oscillating Spindle Sander

Description

The Triton TSP450 Oscillating Spindle Sander is a power tool built for all kinds of sanding, finishing and grinding work. This tool will allow you to efficiently create arcs, curves and other irregular shapes. It has an efficient 3.5 Amp motor with a no load speed of 2000 RPM and oscillation speed of 58 RPM. It also has all the accessories you need like 6 sanding sleeves, rubber drums and table inserts. These accessories may be placed and stored on special inserts found on its sides. This Triton spindle sander is easy to carry anywhere; you can take it at home or you can take it to the shop.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 18.5 X 16 X 20.5 inches
  • Weight: 32.2 pounds
  • Shipping weight: 32.2 pounds
  • Power source: corded-electric
  • Country of origin: China
  • Color: orange and black

Features and Benefits

  • Compact, straightforward design

Even the most experienced hobbyist or woodworker will love a spindle sander with a seamless design. This means that you won’t have to do any complicated adjustments or switching at all. Basically what you see is what you get with the Triton TSP450. You won’t have to worry about keeping it away or storing it afterwards because of its easy and compact design.

  • Rotating and oscillating action

A rotating and oscillating spindle is better than a rotating spindle only. This will improve overall work done by the spindle and improves your work times as well. This spindle sander may be one of a few with a rotating and oscillating movement so far.

  • Powerful motor

This Triton spindle sander has a powerful motor that will let you sand, grind and finish almost all kinds of projects and no matter what type of material you want to work on. A powerful motor also guarantees that your machine won’t stall, stop or pause which could tragically affect the quality of your work.

  • Includes 6 sanding sleeves and matching drums

All the common sanding sleeves and drums are available when you purchase this product. Definitely this gives you more time to experiment with a variety of sanding sleeves and different types of materials. And of course having all the accessories you need the first time you get the product is extra savings on your part. You won’t have to purchase these accessories and attachment separately just to use the tool for the first time.

  • On-board tool storage

Everything is neat and clean with the Triton spindle sander. Your accessories and attachments have a provided area along the sides of the sander. This feature minimizes tool loss and worries as well.

Pros

  • Compact design
  • Easy to use
  • Rotating and oscillating action
  • Powerful motor
  • On-board storage for tools

Cons

  • Noisy to use

3) Grizzly G0538 1/3 HP Oscillating Spindle Sander

Grizzly G0538 1-3 HP Oscillating Spidle Sander

Description

The Grizzly G0538 is an oscillating spindle sander that will allow you to create easy curved edges even if you are just working in your shop because it has a seamless benchtop design. You can carry and use almost everywhere too. It has a powerful motor that will get sanding jobs done with smooth and perfect results. This sander also has a quick change sanding drum to let you change drums easier and faster so you can go to the next task fast.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 17.8 x 22 x 16 inches
  • Weight: 35.6 pounds
  • Shipping weight: 35.6 pounds
  • Power source: corded-electric
  • Color: white and teal

Features and Benefits

  • Space-saving benchtop design

This sander looks different than other sanders because it has a compact design. This reduces the space you need to use and to store a spindle sander which usually takes a lot of space in a working area. Set up is easy too. Just plug the tool, put the sanding sleeve and the corresponding attachment and power on. You won’t have to worry about clean up and storage too since it can fit in a cabinet or just in the corner of your working table.

  • Large table surface

The first thing that you will realize when you see the Grizzly Spindle Sander is that it has a large working surface; it’s like a mini table on your sander. You will be able to grind, sand or finish with utmost precision and work steadily with a spacious surface to use.

  • Six different sanding drum diameters

You will have plenty of different kinds of drum diameters so this means you already have the attachments and accessories you need as soon as you open the box. You can choose from ½ in to 2 inches diameter sanding belts which are the most common for most projects and woodworking jobs.

  • On-board accessories and attachment storage

The attachment storage located along the sides of the machine makes a handy space where the attachments and accessories may be placed for safety. Reduce the worries of missing parts and attachments by placing everything where you can see them.

  • Easy to use design

One of the major pros of this Grizzly spindle sander is that it is easy to use and has no intimidating parts. It looks very straightforward and thus even a beginner hobbyist or woodworker will be able to confidently use it for their work.

Pros

  • Benchtop design
  • Large table surface
  • Six different sanding drum diameters
  • Easy to use
  • Compact

Cons

  • Noisy to use

4) SHOP FOX W1686 1 HP Oscillating Spindle Sander

SHOP FOX W1686 1 HP Oscillating Spindle Sander

Description

The SHOP FOX is like a mini robot; it is an oscillating spindle sander that has been designed for heavy projects and tough working conditions. The spindle has a stroke length of 1 – ½ inch with an oscillating speed of 72 SPM. It has a tall working table to allow you to work without slouching or bowing down. It has a cast iron base and steel table inserts so you can sand, grind or polish steadily and of course it is very heavy so you won’t have any unnecessary movements when you use it. It is ideal for any project and for any kind of material substrate. 

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 41 x 36.3 x 32 inches
  • Weight: 381 pounds
  • Shipping weight: 403 pounds
  • Power source: corded-electric
  • Color: white and black

Features and Benefits

  • Powerful motor

This spindle sander has a very powerful motor which allows it to work with almost all kinds of material. You won’t have to purchase or use another sander just to work with another material. The powerful motor also reduces pausing or jumps which could significantly affect the outcome of your work. You will surely have precise cuts each time.

  • Huge dust port

This is another model with a convenient dust port and therefore you will never have to worry about dust or dirt right in front of your workpiece. Dust and dirt will be automatically removed with the SHOP FOX’s huge 4” diameter dust hole.

  • Large working table

The table of this spindle sander is exceptionally large which allows you to make intricate projects and jobs that need utmost concentration. The large working table also helps you manage your work better compared to smaller and narrower table.

  • Tall table height

This sander also has a tall table compared to other sanders. This height allows the user to see his work better and to concentrate better on the project at hand.

  • With steel table inserts

You can be sure that you are working with a stable and non-movable surface since this sander has been strengthened with steel table inserts. Since all the action happens on top of the table piece it would be wise to reinforce this area with steel inserts. This reduces unnecessary movements as well so you will get the best results no matter when you use this machine.

Pros

  • Powerful motor
  • Large dust port
  • Large and tall working table
  • Steel inserts
  • All accessories and attachments available

Cons

  • Too heavy to take anywhere
  • Too noisy to use

5) Delta SA350K Shopmaster Boss ¼ HP 1,724 RPM Bench Top Spindle Sander with Complete Spindle Sander Set

Delta SA350K Shopmaster Boss Complete Spindle Sander Set

Description

The DELTA Shopmaster Boss is a power spindle sander that has a cast-iron base table to support your work or project. It has a heavy-duty motor that will work seamlessly with its direct drive system for quiet and smooth operation. The spindle body has replaceable oil-impregnated bearings as well as sturdy, ground-steel rods for maximum support. This is another model built with a dust collection system but this time it has a fan that draws in dirt and dust and then deposits all of these in a standard dust bag. This is the only spindle sander that has a toggle switch and removable lock system which prevents access by unauthorized persons.

Product Information

  • Dimensions: 21 x 21 x 15.5 inches
  • Weight: 49 pounds
  • Shipping weight: 55.2 pounds
  • Power source: corded-electric
  • Color: white and black
  • Warranty: 2 years warranty

Features and Benefits

  • Powerful heavy-duty motor

This spindle sander’s motor is one heavy duty workhorse. It has a ¼ HP induction motor with direct drive for smooth operation and with less noise as well. This allows you to work with almost all kinds of substrates and materials while maintaining constant motion and quality. The powerful motor also allows users to work uninterruptedly. No pauses, stops and unnecessary movement that will only affect the overall outcome of your project.

  • Replaceable bearings and ground-steel rods for support

Any minimal vibration can significantly affect your project which is why this spindle sander has loads of support. Along with these super-sized bearings is the tool’s cast-iron table. You won’t have to worry about unnecessary movement what will only affect your work.

  • Dust collection fan

The dust collection fan and port will surely win you over because it will basically remove all dirt and dust from your workstation and thus providing you with a clean and efficient surface to move about. The dust collection system is also easy to use and is huge so this means there will be no trapped particle or piece of wood that would only stop the fan.

  • Pre-drilled base holes for mounting sanding sleeves

Just like most spindle sanders, this one has a special area where you could place all the sanding sleeve accessories and discs. You won’t lose anything as you do your work.

  • Toggle switch

One very unusual feature about this spindle sander is that it can lock down and permit use only to the owner using a special toggle switch.

Pros

  • Heavy-duty motor
  • Cast-iron table
  • Very stable and won’t move
  • Dust collection fan
  • Toggle switch

Cons

  • Too expensive

Reviews / Testimonials

Before I actually made my purchase I was careful to choose the best spindle sander for the job knowing I was very unfortunate with sanders that I chose before. I went to social media and checked what were the most popular sanders in the market. I found out that the WEN, Grizzly and Triton were the most highly-rated and had good reviews.

One of the best reasons why these models ranked higher was that they were very easy to use and were affordable. The WEN 6510 was the obvious winner when it comes to quality and price considering that it had all the favorable features, looked extremely durable.

The Triton was a runner up because of its great features but the accessories storage was not a huge hit among users. This sander also costs much and thus was not a real winner in many social media sites.

The Grizzly spindle sander looked exceptional and that has made it one of the favorites. Its compact, looks very sturdy with is large workspace and tool storage but it costs just as expensive as the Triton model. The WEN 6510 was a clear winner for me and for other people as well and I guess I would be using this spindle sander for plenty more projects to come.

Top Spindle Sanders By Category

Best Power Belt Sanders Comparison Table

Best Power Belt Sanders

Our Rating

Price

WEN 6321 7 Amp Heavy Duty Belt Sander with Dust Bag

Black & Decker DS321 Dragster 7 Amp 3-Inch Belt Sander with Cloth Dust Bag

Generic Mini 1 x 30 Belt Sander 3400 RPM

Best Power Combination Disc and Belt Sanders Comparison Table

Best Power Combination Disc and Belt Sanders

Our Rating

Price

POWERTEC BD1500 Wood Working Belt Disc Sander 1” x 5”

Rockwell RK7866 Belt Disc Sander

RIKON Power Tools 50 – 151 Belt with 5” Disc Sander, 1” x 30” Blue

Best Power Sheet Sanders Comparison Table

Best Power Sheet Sanders

Our Rating

Price

Black & Decker BDEMS600 Mouse Detail Sander

DeWalt D26441 2.4 Amp ¼ Sheet Palm Grip Sander with Cloth Dust Bag

Craftsman Sander ¼ Sheet ¼ Sheet 2.0 Amp 14000 Opm

Alternative Choices

1) POWERTEC OS1400 14” Oscillating Spindle Sander

This spindle sander will allow you to sand and finish contours, arcs, curves and other irregular shapes. It provides 30 oscillations per minute which reduces friction heat to protect wood and to increase sleeve life. This POWERTECH sander has a 14” diameter cast iron table which will let you take control of your work and of course, work more efficiently. It has a built-in dust port and thus will remove dust and dirt away from your workspace. Along the tool’s base are slots where you can place sanding sleeves and discs. You won’t lose these accessories as you use your sander.

2) Rockwell RK9011 Shop Series Oscillating Spindle Sander

This is a power spindle sander with 21 accessories in one. It has a powerful 3.5 amp motor with 58 oscillations per minute. This means it can work on your project without ever having to pause, stop or jolt which could affect the quality of your work and of course the outcome of your work as well. This has handy accessories slots along its sides so you can store everything in one tool. You don’t have to spend time searching for an attachment or an accessory anymore.

3) Delta Woodworking 31 – 483 Heavy Duty Oscillating Bench Spindle Sander

The Delta Woodworking spindle sander is a bench type sander that has a ½ HP 115 volt, 29 OPM motor set in a precision ground cast iron tilting table. It has 5 interchangeable threaded spindles from ¼ inch to 2 inches, 4 table insets and more. It has a convenient dust port and onboard tool and accessories storage. It boasts of a heavy-duty steel frame construction for reduced vibrations. It has more oscillating actions which means the sleeve moves more and thus prolongs its life.

Alternative Choices Comparison Table

Alternative Choices

Our Rating

Price

POWERTEC OS1400 14” Oscillating Spindle Sander

Rockwell RK9011 Shop Series Oscillating Spindle Sander

Delta Woodworking 31 – 483 Heavy Duty Oscillating Bench Spindle Sander

The Final Cut

I recommend the WEN 6510 as an oscillating spindle sander for beginner woodworkers, seasoned workers and for contractors. It is a compact, easy to use and efficient spindle sander that will never let you down. It has a strong motor at ½ HP 3.5 Amp with 58 OPM and 2000 RPM; this ensures that there are no pauses, stops and unnecessary jolts that will affect your work. The WEN spindle sander has all the sanding sleeves you will need in a variety of curvatures (from ½ inch to 3 inches) which means you can work with a variety of curves and even irregular shapes. Onboard storage also allows you to keep all your attachments and accessories handy in case you need anything too.

My favorite feature is the convenient dust port that removes all the dust and dirt from your workspace so you can be clean as you go. You won’t have to deal with messy cleanups and long dusting (and allergies too) when you have this special feature.

And possibly the best part of using the WEN spindle sander is that you can save a lot of money being the least expensive of all. It is true value considering you have the best features for just a fraction of the price of the popular brand. This is why I recommend using this spindle sander for all types of materials and for all kinds of projects as well.

If you are interested in purchasing the WEN6510 Oscillating Spindle Sander, click here to get started.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments