Comparison Review: Bosch Reciprocating Saw vs Milwaukee Reciprocating Saw

Introduction

I have worked in the demolition industry for many years and if there is one very important lesson I’ve learned is to trust your tools. As you would expect, I use different tools from people who construct homes and buildings. I use a different kind of tool that won’t care for any kind of material, any wall, any obstruction. Aside from using my favorite sledgehammer to tear down concrete structures like walls I use a trusty reciprocating saw to easily eat through the wall, drywall, wooden panels and more.

I have full trust in my reciprocating saw which offers pure power per stroke. And as I trust my saw, I also have full faith in two of the most popular and powerful reciprocating saws in the market: the Bosch and the Milwaukee reciprocating saws.

These power saws are superb in what they do. Each one has a powerful motor with amazing degrees of precision even for a demolition tool. I have used a Bosch and  Milwaukee many times and I must say, if I were asked to choose only one, it would be very hard for me to do. But what’s hard for most people like me is not impossible to do.

This is a comparison review of the latest Bosch reciprocating saw and a Milwaukee reciprocating saw. This will help you find the best saw that’s surely right for your construction or demolition needs.

The latest Bosch reciprocating saw is a 1 – 1/8 ---inch, 11 amp power saw that may be used for construction or demolition. This saw is tough and powerful with its variable-speed motor that lets you cut through different materials and remains in control.

This has a dual LED lighting to shine brightly on the surface you wish to cut. With this feature, you can minimize mistakes and keep your cuts steady and clean.

This saw has more features. It offers a tool-less blade change system so you can immediately change the blades without taking too much time. It also comes with an ergonomic handle that has a soft grip so you can grip well during operation.

This Bosch reciprocating saw weighs lighter compared to other reciprocating saws in its class and therefore it could be a good power tool to add to your workshop or worksite toolbox.

Meanwhile, the most updated Milwaukee reciprocating saw is a 12-amp corded saw that gives you 3000 strokes per minute. Call it the Sawzall, it also comes with a variable trigger to help you use it with varying materials and material thicknesses.

This tool lets you remove and replace old blades quickly and with ease. You can remove the old blade without tools with a special latch.

Compared to other reciprocating saws of its class, this one has a vibration reduction system, like an internal counterweight mechanism that reduces vibration, balances the tool and gives you more accuracy in your cuts.

The Milwaukee reciprocating saw also has a powerful motor that will give you total cutting power at 3000 strokes per minute. All these great features and more await you when you use the Milwaukee power saw.

Bosch Reciprocating Saw vs Milwaukee Reciprocating Saw

Product Details

Bosch Reciprocating Saw

Milwaukee Reciprocating Saw

Weight

22.4 x 9.1 x 4.5 inches

22.3 x 11..2 x 5.2 inches

Weight

11.05 pounds

12 pounds

Motor Power

11 amp

120 volts

Accessories

Blade

Blades and carrying case

Ratings

9 out of 10

9 out of 10

Price

Buyer's Guide

How to pick the right product

Shopping for the best reciprocating saw requires time and understanding of the many special features that this special saw has. Shopping and buying a reciprocating saw according to the most popular brand is simply an overstatement. Take time to learn special product parameters in order to get the best value for your money.

  • Check the motor

When out shopping for a reciprocating saw, you will at some point think about whether you would want to use a corded or cordless tool. Some users would keep away from cordless models thinking that they would encounter problems when it comes to power but this may not be so when it comes to updated power saws. Nowadays, many battery-powered tools can work just as hard or even harder than codded ones.

Cordless models will free you from looking for a power outlet. When it comes to corded models, you will find reciprocating saws with 7.5, 10, 12, 13 and even 15-amp motors.

If you are looking for a cordless reciprocating saw model, it would be best to choose a brushless motor. These models may come as expensive but these have many benefits like longer life, improved efficiency, and enhanced tool circuitry. A good example is the Milwaukee One Key reciprocating saw.

  • Check the battery

For cordless reciprocating saw models, you will find several different voltages: 12, 18, 24, 28 and 36 volts. Voltages represent the material difference in the force of the tool and how the battery can perform. You must calculate the watt-hours, if this is not included in the battery information of the tool, to get the best picture of how much a battery can give. To find watt-hours, multiply the voltage by the amp-hours.

  • Keep in mind stroke length and stroke speed

A reciprocating saw’s cutting speed is a function of the stroke length and the stroke speed. Usually, the stroke length is about 1 1/8 inches while cutting speeds vary from 2600 to 3300 strokes per minute. On the other hand, there are compact cordless reciprocating saws with unique designs like the Makita Sub Compact reciprocating saw and the Hackzall from Milwaukee. These saws have lower stroke length and speed but will still cut through material found in tighter spaces.

  • About blade changes

Most updated reciprocating saws offer a tool-less blade change feature, therefore, you won’t find reciprocating saws that need a wrench or a special tool to do so. The most common saws have a spring mechanism to eject the blade when you twist the blade lock. This is handy when you have to change the blade while it is still hot.

  • Variable speed triggers

Look for a variable speed switch or a trigger to allow you to modulate the tool’s speed for different materials. Usually, the cutting speed ranges from 0 to the top speed. You must use a slower speed when cutting metal and at a faster speed when cutting wood.

  • Adjustable shoe

The shoe is the reciprocating saw’s part that surrounds the blade. It stabilizes the saw against the workpiece and reduces vibration due to the saw’s movement. Choose a saw with a show that pivots slightly back and forth to give way for changes in the blade angle as you make the cut.

  • Anti-vibration features

You won’t find a silent reciprocating saw. There will always be some kind of noise or chatter as the saw moves through the material.

However, some manufacturers have made their tools less noisy by using some ergonomic features. The most obvious way to reduce noise is to separate the blade from the rest of the saw body. 

Other updated reciprocating saws have improved counterbalancing weights built inside the tool. Therefore, choose a tool that has effective anti-vibration features as well as ergonomic features to get the most comfortable experience for any kind of project.

  • Choose reciprocating saws with complete accessories

The most common accessories included with a reciprocating saw includes blades, a battery pack (for cordless models), wrenches or tools (for outdated models) and the product manual.

You must choose a product with complete accessories so you will be able to use your tool right out of the box. Take note that products with complete tools are usually more expensive compared to bare tools.

Nevertheless, this will give you more value for your money in the long run.

  • Check the warranty or guarantees of your reciprocating saw

You need a good return policy or if in case you need to return your saw for defects. Keep your receipt and any warranty card. If the warranty, guarantee or return policy of the tool is unclear, contact customer service for details.

Product Comparison Parameters

How do we compare two products?

  • Quality

The overall quality of a reciprocating saw depends on a number of parameters. This starts with the tool’s usability, basic features, ergonomic features, safety features, included accessories and any warranty or guarantee for the product.

The latest Bosch reciprocating saw has full of top quality features for amateur users and professional users alike. This power saw has an 11-amp motor that will give you full power to rip through different materials.

This has dual LED lights that shine brightly so you can see the material you are working on. This comes with a tool-less blade replacement system so you can have effortless blade replacement and installation. 

This Bosch reciprocating saw also has quality ergonomic features. It will remain comfortable even when you use it for a long period of time with its ergonomic handle with a soft grip.

This also comes with a variable speed trigger so you will have full control over your cuts. You can rip through sheet metal or wood panels easily and thoroughly when you use this saw with variable speeds. All these quality features make this power saw a good addition to your power tool arsenal at the worksite or at your workshop. 

Meanwhile, the latest Milwaukee reciprocating saw is not too far behind when it comes to quality. This saw comes with a quick lock technology that will let you remove, replace or install blades without tools. The secret is the latch found on the side of the unit that conveniently grips the blade; quickly releasing this latch lets you change your blades without using any kind of tool.

This also comes with a quality vibration reduction feature that makes the tool more comfortable to use. A convenient counterweight mechanism inside the tool body keeps the tool steady to give you accurate cuts all the time.

This Milwaukee reciprocating saw has a high powered motor that will work at speeds up to 3000 strokes per minute depending on how much you press down on the convenient variable speed trigger.

This comes with a carrying case made from very durable polyurethane so you can carry your tool to wherever you wish to go.

  • Blades

The Bosch plunge saw and the Festool plunge saw use replaceable circular blades made from tough materials. These blades will let you cut through different materials and will allow you to use this saw for a variety of projects and applications as well. A power saw is only as good as its blade so make sure to use only genuine saw blades.

  • Weight

The Bosch plunge saw weighs less than 10 pounds and because this is light, you can use this in the field or to the worksite. The Festool plunge saw weighs less than 5 pounds which means it is lighter than the Bosch plunge saw and therefore it’s easier to take around.

1) Bosch Reciprocating Saw

Why Use the Bosch Reciprocating Saw and Who Is It For?

The Bosch reciprocating saw is for people who want a lightweight, easy to use and tough saw for construction or demolition. It is for anyone looking for a variable speed, tool-less saw built for many types of projects. You can use this whether you are new to reciprocating saws because this is light and easy to use. Whether you are a homeowner, hobbyist, contractor, carpenter or a part of a demolition team, you will get good value when you use this power saw.

Review

The most updated Bosch reciprocating saw is a 1- 1/8 – inch saw with an 11-amp motor which could be an essential part of your construction or demolition worksite.

This saw has a powerful motor that allows you to rip through different materials including wood, metal, and acrylic. You can tear down wooden walls, saw through sheet metal, carve through ice or cut any construction material with ease with this powerful saw. 

This Bosch power saw comes with dual LEDs to illuminate your working area. This feature increases accuracy by improving the line of sight and prevents costly mistakes as well.

This is an updated model that has a tool-less blade replacement and attachment system. You can effortlessly remove old blades and replace these with new ones without causing any delays in work hours.

It also has an ergonomic handle with a soft grip so you can hold the tool firmly as you make cuts. And this reciprocating saw also has a variable speed trigger so you can have full cutting control when you are working on different materials.

This is a corded model so you need to rely on power cords and extension cords but nevertheless, you get uninterrupted cutting power always.

Main Features

  • 11-amp motor
  • Dual LED to improve cutting zones
  • Tool-less blade change system
  • Ergonomic handle with a soft grip
  • Variable speed trigger
  • Corded, electric model
  • Weighs only 11 pounds
  • Covered with a 1-year manufacturer’s warranty and a 30-day money back guarantee
  • For construction and demolition jobs

Q&As

Where do you take your Bosch reciprocating saw in case it needs to be repaired?

If you have a saw under warranty, take this to an authorized service center for professional and quality service and parts replacement. Always take your receipt with you to avail of its 1-year manufacturer’s warranty. If you saw is no longer under warranty, take it still to an authorized service center for repairs and parts replacement.

Are blades for the Bosch reciprocating saw available online?

Yes, reciprocating saw blades for this Bosch saw are available online. Usually, blades are sold in packs of 5 or more. You can save money by buying blades in bulk. You may also purchase genuine blades from Bosch reciprocating saw dealers near you or from a local shop that sells Bosch tools.

Can you use just any kind of blade for this Bosch reciprocating saw?

You can’t use just any kind of straight blade or saw blade for this Bosch reciprocating saw. Use only appropriate saws for this model and never generic straight saws. These will only end up ruining your reciprocating saw’s performance.

How do you change the blade of this Bosch reciprocating saw?

A special tool-less mechanism is found near the blade. All you need to do is to remove this and you can now easily replace dull blades. This makes it easier for you to remove blades too while it is still hot from use.

How do you maintain or clean this Bosch reciprocating saw?

Check product manual or manufacturer’s information on how to maintain your Bosch reciprocating saw. You must use a soft, clean and dry cloth to wipe away dirt and dust on your saw blades. Use a soft brush to remove dirt from the blades if this is harder to remove. Wipe dust and dirt from the saw body as well. Always replace damaged, broken or chipped saw blades because this can be unsafe to use and can affect the performance of your saw.

Do I need to undergo special training to use a Bosch reciprocating saw?

No, you don’t need to undergo special training to use this Bosch reciprocating saw. You can check out videos and step by step instructions on how to use this saw. If you have questions call customer service for timely help.

Pros

  • Powerful variable speed motor.
  • You can rip through different materials.
  • Very light so you can take it anywhere.
  • Tool-less blade replacement and attachment design.
  • Dual LEDs
  • Ergonomic handles.

Cons

  • Corded model
  • You can’t really take it far without a working outlet.
  • Does not come with spare blades.
  • Does not have any anti-vibration features.

2) Milwaukee Reciprocating Saw

Why Use the Milwaukee Reciprocating Saw and Who Is It For?

The Milwaukee reciprocating saw is for people who need a stable, accurate saw with vibration-less features and ergonomic features. It is for people who want a handy, compact and convenient saw to use on the field. It is for first-time users too because this saw is lightweight and easy to use. It is also for professionals like carpenters, contractors, and woodworkers.

Review

When it comes to demolition jobs a few tough reciprocating saws come to mind and one of this is the Sawzall from Milwaukee. This is the latest Milwaukee reciprocating saw which has plenty of features to help you in your demolition work.

It can tackle any kind of material thrown its way because it’s designed to perform in the toughest environments. It has a powerful 12-amp motor that can rip through different materials. It will give you long-lasting power for more jobs to come. This is a high-impact reciprocating saw because of its design.

The gear protecting clutch improves gear and motor life by absorbing impact forces. It has a QUIK-LOK blade clamp that lets you make fast and efficient blade changes without using any kind of tool. You only need to pull a latch found along the side of the tool to release the blade and put the latch back when the blade has been replaced

It comes with a counterweight mechanism that will help you reduce vibrations to give you smoother operations and reduces mistakes as you work. You can use this for demolition work, construction work or for various DIY projects at home or in the field. This is a corded model and therefore you need a very long extension cord if you plan to use it outdoors or on the worksite.

Main Features

  • 12-amp motor
  • QUIK LOK system for tool-less blade replacement
  • Vibration reduction features
  • Gear-protecting clutch
  • High-powered motor at 3000 strokes per minute
  • Carrying case made of high-impact rated polyurethane
  • Corded electric model
  • Ergonomic design
  • Easy to use
  • For demolition or construction use

Q&As

How do you maintain a Milwaukee reciprocating saw?

Check the product manual for specific tips on how to maintain this saw. Use a clean dry cloth to wipe away debris and dust from the blade and the saw body. Remove broken or dull blades to ready your saw for the next project.

How do you find out if your Milwaukee reciprocating saw is still under warranty?

Check the date of your receipt. Contact Milwaukee customer service or your distributor about their warranty or guarantee. Saws that are still under warranty may enjoy special discounts or free service or parts replacement.

Can you use any kind of saw blade for the Milwaukee reciprocating saw?

No, you cannot use just any kind of saw blade for this reciprocating saw. Check your product manual for the ideal saw blades for this power saw. Buy only genuine Milwaukee blades because generic blades can ruin the performance of your saw.

Where do you take a Milwaukee reciprocating saw that is no longer under warranty for repairs?

If your reciprocating saw is no longer under warranty, take it to an authorized service center for repairs. Although you won’t get free service or repairs, your Milwaukee saw deserves professional and quality repairs and of course genuine parts replacement. If you don’t know where a local service center is found, contact Milwaukee for details.

Do you use a special brush or cloth to clean a Milwaukee reciprocating saw?

There is no special brush or tool to clean a Milwaukee reciprocating saw. Use a soft clean cloth or a soft toothbrush to clean your saw blade and saw the body. This makes hard to remove dirt and dust easier to remove and will preserve the performance of your reciprocating saw.

Where do I purchase blades and accessories for my Milwaukee reciprocating saw?

You can purchase genuine blades and accessories for this Milwaukee reciprocating saw online or from accredited or authorized dealers near you.

Pros

  • Powerful motor
  • Tough for construction and demolition sites.
  • Tool-less design.
  • A latch that will unhitch the blade.
  • Gear-protecting clutch that protects the saw’s components.
  • Vibration reduction features.
  • You get perfect cuts and a clean line of sight.
  • Comes with a carrying case.

Cons

  • Does not come with LED lights.
  • Minimal ergonomic features. very long extension cord.
  • Does not come with a spare blade.
  • You still need to order extra blades in case the original breaks or dulls.

The Final Cut

The Bosch reciprocating saw and the Milwaukee reciprocating saw are both lightweight and compact and therefore good power saws to take to a worksite, construction site or demolition site. Both are corded so you need a very long extension cord to work. Corded models tend to be a hassle if you need to work steadily and efficiently because you need to deal with a power cord.

But when it comes to design, the Milwaukee tops the Bosch. A few examples can sustain this fact. The Milwaukee has a better motor, improved cutting ability and has anti-vibration features. All these can add to a quality reciprocating saw. The Milwaukee also has an easier tool-less QUIK LOK system that uses a latch to loosen and tighten the blade assembly.

All-in-all, the Milwaukee is a better choice when it comes to power and usability. But when you think about weight and other features, both saws have almost the same properties. 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments