Comparison Review: Scroll Saw vs Band Saw vs Jigsaw

Introduction

When you are setting up your woodworking station you need to consider a few power tools that will give your projects a boost. Three of the best and the most popular saws to consider are the scroll saw band saw and a jigsaw. Each of these saws has their own uses plus each has its own features as well. Learning how these saws work will help you shop for the best one for your woodworking needs.

The scroll saw is a handy electric saw that is used to cut intricate curves on a variety of materials like wood, metal and other materials. This saw is powerful but gentle enough to cut delicate patterns and to be used in many applications. It is more preferred than coping saws or fretsaws.

A band saw is a saw that has a long sharp blade. The term band came from the sharp and continuous band of toothed metal stretched between two or more wheels to cut the material. A band saw is very useful for woodworking, metalworking and also for lumbering or cutting large pieces of material.

A jigsaw is a powerful tool that has an electric motor and a reciprocating saw blade. It has a bevel function so you can cut angles up to 45 degrees. It is a powerful saw that is used to cut irregular curves like stenciled designs in a variety of materials.

This is a comparison review of the scroll saw, band saw and jigsaw which highlights the good points and bad points of each. You will be able to find the best power saw you need for your woodworking projects in no time.

Scroll Saw vs Band Saw vs Jigsaw

Product Details

Scroll Saw

Band Saw

Jigsaw

Weight

5 to 20 pounds

15 to 40 pounds

10 to 40 pounds

Motor Power

120 volts

120 volts

120 volts

Accessories

A variety of cutting blades

Bandsaw, hex wrench, kit box

Jigsaw blades

Price

Buyer's Guide

How to choose the right product

A power saw will help you make different projects in a more efficient manner. There is no need to cut materials manually with basic cutting tools. When it comes to buying power cutting tools like a scroll saw, band saw and jigsaw, you need to keep the following key features in mind.

  • Your saw’s power input

The power input of any kind of power tool determines if the tool can take larger and thicker materials. Power input equals the amount of power the motor needs to run. The greater the watts the more powerful the motor is. And the more powerful a motor is, the easier for the tool to tackle larger and more complicated materials.

  • Maximum cutting capabilities

Maximum cutting power is his thickest material that the saw can cut. This is a value according to the manufacturer. This gauges if the saw can take the type of material that you want to cut. For instance, if you are in the market for a saw to cut thick wooden panels then you look at the maximum cutting capabilities of the saw before you make a decision.

  • Choose keyless or tool-less blade changes

This is a special feature that allows you to change blades without using a tool or a wrench. This feature lets you safely and efficiently change blades without affecting your workflow. Most updated power saws come with this special feature.

  • Choose a tool with a variable speed motor

A power saw with a variable speed motor modulates the speed of the blade depending on the material you wish to cut. Variable speed makes a power tool more versatile and this is usually seen in updated power saws like scroll, band and miter saws.

  • Dust extraction

A tool with a dust extraction feature will remove dust and dirt from your workplace. This is a blessing for people using scroll saws, table saws, and miter saws. This feature makes your workspace cleaner and safer since you can easily see the material you are cutting.

  • Power saws with complete accessories

Choose power tools that come in a set so you can have accessories to use as soon as you take your saw home. Buying a bare tool seems cheaper but in the end, you will be paying for more when you buy accessories piece by piece.

Product Comparison Parameters

How do we compare two products?

  • Quality

The quality of a power saw is determined by many factors. The material and make of the tool, its primary features, ergonomic features and accessories will all determine the quality of the power saw.

The scroll saw's portability, motor power, and precision will tell you if the saw is of high or poor quality. The jigsaw's features overall make and design and precision will all determine the saw's quality.

Meanwhile, a band saw and the jigsaw is not too far behind. Quality is measured by its good motor, cutting ability, precision, ergonomic features and more. Considering all these will help you find the ideal power cutting tool that’s right for your woodworking needs.

  • Weight

Scroll saws, band saws, and jigsaws are mostly lightweight. And because these are lightweight, these are usually used for DIY applications and for light carpentry, repair work and more.

  • Blades

The scroll, band, and jigsaw use a different kind of saw blade. This is a straight blade with varying number of teeth and depth. The number of teeth and the depth of the blade differ when it comes to the type blade and the material to cut or worked on. Blades are replaceable and replacement blades are available from online shopping sites and from local tool shops and stores.

1) Scroll Saw

Why Use the Scroll Saw and Who’s it For

A scroll saw is for people who want an efficient, precise electro saw that will cut through different materials to make delicate patterns. This saw is for woodworkers, contractors, decorators and DIY enthusiasts.

Review

The scroll saw is a portable and efficient electric saw used to cut intricate curves on a variety of materials like wood, metal and more. This is a powerful saw but is also gentle enough to cut delicate patterns. It can be used on a variety of applications that no other power cutting tools can. It is more preferred than coping saws or fretsaws because of its power, versatility and lightweight features.

Main Features

  • With a sharp and powerful blade
  • Can cut delicate patterns and shapes
  • Updated models have ergonomic features
  • Latest models have updated safety features
  • Strong enough to cut through different materials
  • With corded and cordless models available.

Q&As

Where do you purchase extra blades for a scroll saw?

You can purchase extra blades online or you may do so from local suppliers and shops that sell genuine scroll saw blades.

What do you use to clean and maintain a scroll saw?

Check manufacturer’s instructions on how to clean a specific scroll saw the product. A scroll saw should be wiped clean using a soft, clean cloth to remove dirt and dust.

What to do with a damaged scroll saw?

You must take your saw to an accredited repair center for professional repairs and genuine parts replacement.

Pros

  • Let’s you cut different shapes and patterns easily and quickly.
  • Allows you to save time and reduce material wastage.
  • Can make accurate cuts each time.

Cons

  • Not for thick and heavier materials.
  • Cordless models require frequent charging and recharging.

2) Band Saw

Why Use a Band Saw and Who is It For?

A band saw is a powerful saw that can slice through different materials: from thin pieces of wood to thick slabs of lumber. If you are a carpenter, general contractor, homeowner or a professional woodworker, you will surely love to use a band saw to make precise cuts.

Review

A band saw is a saw with a long sharp blade. The term band is from the sharp and continuous band of toothed metal stretched between two or more wheels to cut any kind of material. A band saw is for woodworking, metalworking and also for lumbering or cutting large pieces of material for different projects.

Main Features

  • Has a sharp blade
  • With a strong motor
  • Updated models have ergonomic features
  • Latest models have updated safety features
  • This is strong enough to cut through a variety of materials
  • With corded and cordless models available.

Q&As

Can you buy a band saw online or from a local store?

Yes, you can buy a brand new band saw online from an authorized online store as well as a local store. Make sure that you are buying only genuine band saws from authorized dealers.

How do you maintain a band saw?

Wipe the blade of a band saw with a soft, clean and dry piece of cloth. Wipe the body of the saw as well. Make sure that your saw blades are sharp and clean so these will be ready for use the next time you need to cut something.

Where do you purchase a new or replacement blade for your band saw?

You can buy new or replacement blades for your band saw from any local shop or store. You may also purchase one online. Never use generic blades or accessories for your saw because doing so can affect the way you use your band saw.

Pros

  • Will cut a variety of materials.
  • Latest models come with ergonomic features.
  • Are available in corded and cordless models.

Cons

  • The cordless model needs a spare battery pack.
  • Band saws should be regularly maintained.

3) Jigsaw

Why Use a Jigsaw and Who Is It For?

A jigsaw is a powerful tool that has an electric motor and has the ability to cut different shapes and patterns. This tool is for people who want a reliable and handy daw to cut different shapes and forms. It is for DIY and for general contractor use.

Review

A jigsaw is popular and versatile that is used to cut through a variety of materials. This is for people who want a handy, efficient and lightweight saw to cut different shapes and compound bevel cuts in boards as well as a variety of materials. The key to making efficient cuts in a jigsaw is to use the right kind of blade. This is why a jigsaw comes with a variety of blades each one with specific uses

Main Features

  • Sharp reciprocating blade
  • With safety switches
  • With ergonomic handles
  • May be corded or cordless
  • Will work with a variety of materials

Q&As

How do you clean a jigsaw saw?

Use a clean soft cloth to remove dirt, grime, and dust over the saw body and especially the blades. Wipe it clean but don’t use soap and water. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions on how to clean and maintain the type of jigsaw you want to purchase.

Where do you buy blades and accessories for your jigsaw?

You can purchase blades and accessories for your jigsaw from online or from local shops and stores. Only use genuine parts especially blades because generic blades can affect the way you use y our power saw.

Where do you take your jigsaw for repairs?

If your jigsaw is still under warranty, take it to an authorized service center to have it serviced. Only an accredited service center will be able to repair your jigsaw efficiently. If your tool is no longer under warranty, take it to an authorized service center as well for the best service your power tool needs.

Pros

  • Can make accurate and quick cuts.
  • The jigsaw will make intricate cuts.
  • The jigsaw is handy for DIY.

Cons

  • The jigsaw is not very efficient when it comes to large materials.
  • A cordless jigsaw may lose battery power fast.

The Final Cut

When it comes to an effective tool to use for DIY, general carpentry and for hobbies, you can use either the scroll saw, bands saw or jigsaw.

Each one has its own good points, great features, and amazing cutting abilities.

If you are looking for a reliable cutting tool then any of these will come in handy. Shop smart and soon you will have the right cutting tool for your needs.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments